Guardians & Reds & Athletics

Submitted by: kzeke

Guardians

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Paul Blackburn30MajorsLRPSPMedium215.687.66.17.69.1
JD Davis31Majors3B1BMedium111.32.58.878.810.6
Spencer Steer26Majors3BLow654.424.829.723.729.735.6

Total Value:

46.10

Reds

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Triston McKenzie27MajorsSPLow354.3945.336.245.354.3

Total Value:

45.3

Athletics

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Estevan Florial26MajorsOFMedium5000000
Jhonkensy Noel22Minors1B0001.81.41.82.2
Chase Petty20MinorsSP0001310.41315.6

Total Value:

14.8

General Manager Badge
SportsCoach

Cleveland wants Steer, but no one else in this deal... Cleveland had a legit chance to get Davis and they didnt...

temporary account

Reds are not trading Steer and A's also say no. I don't see your constant fascination with two mediocre, short-term assets. Show some patience.

BigBat

The real value here for Cleveland is Steer and I'd probably pull the trigger because of him. However, I would prefer to not have Davis in the deal.

kzeke

One person say's Reds are not giving up Steer, the other says Cleveland is not giving up McKenzie. Yet, would it benefit both teams? Yes, Cleveland gets another everyday starting outfielder who can hit for power (platoon Brennan and Freeman) and the Reds get probably their #1 or #2. People with problems with this trade are probably the same people who wanted to clown me for putting Espino and Straw in trades.........

General Manager Badge
grover

Down vote for Oakland. Trading two legit MLB players for what is essentially 1 pitching prospect (that has struggled to build his workload) and roster fill does not make sense for the A's.

BigBat

I don't blame you for the down vote here grover and the A's don't really need to be involved anyway. The Reds could use McKenzie and the Guardians would be better with Steer. McKenzie for Steer and Petty makes a lot more sense.

NEWSLETTER? SURE, SIGN ME UP!