Honestly, I'd say the Jays offer would be a bit light here. Alcantara is looking more like himself and has 2.5 years of control left, and Cabrera is way undervalued. This site has Mitch Kellar worth $30M and Cabrera worth $15M. Both have same control, but Kellar signed an extension that has him earning $15 or more per year while Cabrera goes through arbitration at the same time and makes under $2 this year. His pure stuff is better than Kellar but isn't a workhorse like him. I'd say they're a push, so Cabrera should be valued on here at about $25-30M. On top of that, most trades for pitching last year at the deadline were being rejected on this site, so you have to be giving up more than you're getting. And I think they should consider multiple starters if the opportunity is there. Can't assume Scherzer stays healthy from here on out, or Lauer continuing to throw like an ace.