AtlanticPhilsPTLucas Borja
on July 2, 2019 at 8:53 pm
I like guy you traded for, but i don’t like the prospects you gave up, especially Haseley and Garcia, Haseley will be the future starting LF(Maybe CF) and Garcia is an amazing SS who had drawn comparsions to Francisco Lindor. Boyd is good but i woudn’t deal our future in a season where we might not win the division. Just my opinion.
Garcia’s value has been fluctuating. He’s down a bit this year due to poor performance, so much so that some Phillies fans I’ve talked to have written him off. But he’s still young, and prospect development is not linear, so he could easily turn that around.
AtlanticPhilsPTLucas Borja
on July 2, 2019 at 9:48 pm
He started off slow but he is only 20, and Phillies fans like to give up on prospects too quickly just like they did to Bohm and Moniak(both are having great bouncebacks), we would have to give up too much for boyd, in a season where we currently have a 25% shot of making the playoffs(Fangraphs) I don’t know if it would be the right move to do a trade of this magnitude.
I like guy you traded for, but i don’t like the prospects you gave up, especially Haseley and Garcia, Haseley will be the future starting LF(Maybe CF) and Garcia is an amazing SS who had drawn comparsions to Francisco Lindor. Boyd is good but i woudn’t deal our future in a season where we might not win the division. Just my opinion.
Btw not saying Garcia will be Lindor, his ceiling is that.
Garcia’s value has been fluctuating. He’s down a bit this year due to poor performance, so much so that some Phillies fans I’ve talked to have written him off. But he’s still young, and prospect development is not linear, so he could easily turn that around.
He started off slow but he is only 20, and Phillies fans like to give up on prospects too quickly just like they did to Bohm and Moniak(both are having great bouncebacks), we would have to give up too much for boyd, in a season where we currently have a 25% shot of making the playoffs(Fangraphs) I don’t know if it would be the right move to do a trade of this magnitude.