Cubs & Guardians




Cubs & Guardians

May 5, 2023


Name Age Level P1 P2 Availablility Years AFV Salary Surplus Low Median High
Allen Minors LHP 15.7 12.6 15.7 18.8
Bibee Minors RHP 18.2 14.6 18.2 21.8


Name Age Level P1 P2 Availablility Years AFV Salary Surplus Low Median High
Kilian Minors RHP 5.6 4.5 5.6 6.7
Morel 24 Majors 3B Medium 5.8 43.7 23.6 20 16 20 24.1
  1. Bennett Johnson

    BTV lowered Morel’s evaluation from 28.2 to 20 (I guess cause he was only hitting .375 in AAA) or this would have been Morel straight up for Bible and Allen.

    • Ty Archy

      You are an idiot for even thinking Cleveland would do this… We have stated over and over again, Bibee is ranked the same as Williams who is what 43 on here… You couldn’t get Bibee from Cleveland if you traded us your entire top 30 prospect list…

      Bibee is Bieber plus 5 mph… Bibee has a great chance of winning a Cy Young if he stays healthy…

  2. J.M. F.

    Benjo is just trying to pick a fight with Cleveland posters like he did last season. Ignore him and he will move on. He knows damn well that Cleveland would never do this.

    • Ty Archy

      I know, but I actually would like to have legit discussions ya know? This site is a lot of fun, when you can honestly have non- trolling trade ideas…

  3. Bennett Johnson

    Sport Coat,

    You’re a riot. First you call me an “idiot,” then lecture about “non-trolling trade ideas” Morel is much more of a sure thing than either Bibee or Allen. Plus, he was at 28.2 before BTV lowered him for some inexplicable reason. Fair trade. I might move Alcantara, but only if you’re nice. Let me know if you’re interested.


    Good to hear from you ol’ buddy. What’s JMF short for, Joe Medwick Fan? You sound like an old-timer. Don’t be sore because your team can’t score!!! Ha! I’m just warming up for trade deadline. This is my spring training. Just getting my chops back.

    You two, plus BigBag are my best friends on BTV. Looking forward to makin’ some deals. Sorry, don’t ask about Happ this year. Full no-trade clause.

    • Big Bat

      Morel is garbage in comparison to Bibee and Allen. He’d be lucky to be in Cleveland’s top 10 prospects.

  4. Bennett Johnson

    Hey Bug Bite

    Morel proved last season he belongs in the bigs, something your guys have yet to do. Plus, he’s tearing up AAA. I know you think Cleveland prospects walk on water. Last year it was Nolan Jones. Is he even in baseball any longer?

    • John Bitzer

      Nolan Jones is tearing up AAA for the Rockies, to whom he was traded a while ago.

    • Big Bat

      Hey Ben Ho

      Morel has sucked until his recent hot streak after being demoted because he couldn’t hit ML pitching. He has not proven anything at the ML level and you can go ahead and keep your wonderful, little player and we’ll go ahead and keep our fantastic young SP. Chernoff isn’t an idiot so I don’t have to worry about him making a ridiculous deal like this one. This is the type of deal that gets assistant GM’s fired and never hired again. You must have bumped your head Ben Dover.

      I was never a huge fan of Jones if we’re being honest which is why I had him in so many trade deals. Nice name drop though big fella.

  5. Bennett Johnson

    Hey BigButt

    Won’t find me down rapping Cleveland FO. Second best 2022 Cost Per Win. Playoff team. Lot better than stupid Jed Hoyer. His mantra this year is “leadership.” Bringing in all these “leaders.” Hosmer, Swanson, Mancini, etc. Not sure who they’re supposed to lead. I always thought that it was the manager and coaches who were supposed to lead. Players there to win.

    Anyway, they finally brought up Morel. I agree the jury is still out. Same on Mervis. Wesneski looks like he’s coming around, ,so we probably won’t be needing your overhyped pitchers. But it’s always nice chatting with you, dude!

Submit a Comment